Roth IRA Aggregation Rules

Roth Aggregation and Roth Account Arrangements

How the IRS Actually Treats Your Roth Accounts

One of the most misunderstood aspects of Roth planning is how the IRS aggregates Roth accounts and how that aggregation interacts with account structure, conversions, ordering rules, and withdrawals. Most people assume that each Roth account stands alone. That assumption is wrong—and it’s where many strategies either quietly succeed or unexpectedly fail.

The IRS does not care how many Roth accounts you open, where they are held, or how neatly they are labeled. What matters is how the tax code aggregates and classifies Roth dollars. Understanding this distinction is essential for anyone using Roth accounts strategically—especially under modern tax law and the post-SECURE 2.0 environment.

What “Roth Aggregation” Actually Means

Roth aggregation refers to how the IRS treats multiple Roth accounts as a single tax construct for certain rules. This applies primarily to Roth IRAs, not employer plans.

Under the tax code, all Roth IRAs you own are treated as one Roth IRA for tax purposes. This aggregation affects:

  • Withdrawal ordering rules
  • Five-year clocks
  • Qualification of earnings
  • Reporting of distributions

This is true regardless of:

  • How many Roth IRAs you have
  • Which custodian holds them
  • Whether they were funded by contributions, conversions, or rollovers

The IRS collapses them conceptually into one aggregated Roth IRA.

Roth IRAs: Fully Aggregated by Law

All Roth IRAs are aggregated together. Period.

That means:

  • Contributions across all Roth IRAs are pooled
  • Conversions across all Roth IRAs are pooled
  • Earnings across all Roth IRAs are pooled
  • Ordering rules apply across the aggregate, not per account

You cannot “isolate” Roth IRA dollars by opening separate Roth IRAs. Multiple accounts may exist operationally, but they are irrelevant for tax sequencing.

This is why Roth ordering rules work cleanly:

the IRS applies them once, to the totality of your Roth IRA universe.

Roth 401(k)s Are Not Aggregated with Roth IRAs

Roth 401(k)s are governed by employer plan rules, not IRA rules. As a result:

  • Roth 401(k)s are not aggregated with Roth IRAs
  • Roth 401(k)s do not follow Roth IRA ordering rules
  • Withdrawals from Roth 401(k)s are pro-rata between contributions and earnings
  • Each Roth 401(k) plan stands on its own

This separation is intentional in the tax code and creates a critical planning distinction.

Once a Roth 401(k) is rolled into a Roth IRA, however, it loses its separate identity and becomes part of the aggregated Roth IRA pool.

Aggregation vs Arrangement: The Key Distinction

This is one of the most important conceptual distinctions you’ve emphasized:

  • Aggregation is how the IRS taxes Roth accounts
  • Arrangement is how you structure accounts operationally

You cannot change aggregation.

You can control arrangement.

Strategic Roth planning lives in the arrangement layer, not the aggregation layer.

Roth Account Arrangements: Why Structure Still Matters

Even though Roth IRAs are aggregated for tax purposes, account arrangement still matters for execution, clarity, and control.

Strategic reasons to maintain multiple Roth IRAs include:

  • Separating contribution Roths from conversion Roths for tracking
  • Segregating conversions by year for documentation clarity
  • Managing investment risk differently across Roth “sub-accounts”
  • Simplifying audit defense and record-keeping
  • Supporting complex multi-year conversion strategies

These arrangements do not change tax outcomes—but they dramatically improve operational precision.

Conversions and Aggregation: How the IRS Sees Them

Roth conversions are aggregated with all other Roth IRA dollars, but they are still tracked by year for penalty purposes.

Important principles:

  • Converted principal is never taxed again
  • Each conversion has its own five-year penalty clock
  • Withdrawals follow FIFO ordering across all conversions
  • The IRS does not care which Roth IRA received the conversion

This is why clean conversion tracking is essential in advanced strategies.

Ordering Rules Operate on the Aggregate

Roth ordering rules apply after aggregation, not per account.

The IRS always treats withdrawals in this order:

  1. Aggregate Roth contributions
  2. Aggregate Roth conversions (oldest first)
  3. Aggregate Roth earnings

This sequencing applies regardless of which Roth IRA you withdraw from.

You cannot “target” earnings or conversions by choosing a specific account.

Why Rollovers Matter: Collapsing Structures Intentionally

When Roth 401(k)s are rolled into Roth IRAs, several things happen at once:

  • Employer plan restrictions disappear
  • Pro-rata withdrawal rules disappear
  • Roth IRA ordering rules take over
  • Aggregation expands to include the rolled funds

This is why many strategies treat the Roth IRA as the final destination, even if accumulation occurred elsewhere.

SECURE 2.0 and the 2026 Context

SECURE 2.0 and the 2026 updates did not change Roth aggregation rules—but they increased their importance.

Key contextual shifts:

  • Mandatory Roth catch-ups increase Roth balances system-wide
  • More conversions increase the need for precise tracking
  • Roth IRAs remain RMD-free
  • Aggregation rules continue unchanged

As Roth usage expands, misunderstanding aggregation becomes more costly.

Common Aggregation Mistakes

Most Roth planning failures stem from confusing accounts with tax treatment.

Common errors include:

  • Believing separate Roth IRAs are taxed separately
  • Assuming Roth 401(k) rules apply after rollover
  • Poor tracking of conversion years
  • Assuming custodial statements determine ordering
  • Designing strategies that fight aggregation instead of using it

Aggregation is not a flaw—it is the framework.

Strategic Takeaway

The Roth is not “one account.”

It is a tax construct with multiple containers.

You cannot out-engineer aggregation.

But you can design arrangements that work with it.

Those who understand Roth aggregation gain:

  • Predictable tax outcomes
  • Early-retirement flexibility
  • Clean conversion ladders
  • Long-term tax control

Those who don’t are guessing.

Final Thoughts

Roth aggregation is not optional, negotiable, or obscure. It is foundational. It has survived decades of tax law, multiple acts of Congress, and now SECURE 2.0 and the 2026 updates.

The IRS aggregates.

You arrange.

And mastery lives in knowing the difference.

Back to top